Friday, February 18, 2011
News Flash: My Princess Boy
Premature Sex and the Media
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/06/09/opinion/09dowd.html
Growing up in Bethesda Maryland, and having four brothers that attended the Landon School for all 10 years, I couldn’t help but pick an article from the New York Times titled “Their Dangerous Swagger.” Maureen Dowd writes about a fantasy football league that was set up by a group of 8th graders from the Landon school. Instead of using NFL football stars, they used girls from the area in their grade to create the teams. The criteria for a good “player” included bra size, weight, personality traits, height, and whether or not they were willing to get “down and dirty.” Dowd writes, “The young woman who was the “top pick” was described by one of the boys in a team profile he put up online as “sweet, outgoing, friendly, willing to get down and dirty and [expletive] party. Coming in at 90 pounds, 5’2 and a bra size 34d.” She would be a special asset to the team, he noted, because her mother “is quite the cougar herself.” Before they got caught, the boys planned a “opening day party” where they had made t-shirts and planned to invite the girls over and score points by how many sexual meetings they had with them.
If Douglass were to have written her book Enlightened Sexism in a year or two, I think that this scandal would have been good evidence to prove her point about enlightened sexism. Enlightened Sexism is the idea that women have achieved their rights and now it is time for them to focus on their physical appearance and materialistic world. In the third wave of feminism, the women’s movement has been focusing on the problem of women being sexually objectified. Although we may have our basic rights as citizens, the media, and both men and women are contributing to the idea of enlightened sexism. There is no doubt in my mind that sexual advances and encounters are starting at a younger age now because of the media. These 8th graders that were apart of this scandal had probably been watching MTV for years leading up to the incident. Shows like Jersey Shore, Real World, Exposed, and Parental Control objectify women and tend to concentrate on their bodies’ and image rather then their accomplishments and life goals. In the Jersey Shore alone, terms like “grenades”, “GFA/GFF”, “bomb”, “Poundin’ it out” and many more. Grenades are considered large women who are hard to look at. GFA and GFF stand for Grenade Free America, and Grenade Free Foundation. A bomb is a stubborn woman who cannot be easily seduced. Poundin it out refers to sexual intercourse and the male cast of this show usually uses this term. In the Jersey Shore alone, terms are being created and it makes male teenagers across the nation think that it is socially acceptable to use such degrading terms. It also gives female teenagers the impression that it is okay to dress like Snooki and J-woww, and that the norm is for boys to bring you back to their sex lair. I think that if the media concentrated less on the “hook up” scene and didn’t have so many shows and movies about the world of sex, then we could have steered this new generation of kids away from being sexually aware and advanced at such a young age.
When I was in 8th grade, our brains were not wired to think about how far we would go sexually. The biggest scandal of my 8th grade year was when a girl performed oral sex on her boyfriend. Everyone in the D.C area found out about it because it was against our societal norms. Although I do think how mature and sexually advanced a teenager is depends on context, such as whom they were raised by and where they grew up, I think that most of it depends on the media and the social norms that are constantly changing. A teenager who has parental control and is raised well in an environment with limited drugs and alcohol is more likely to sexually mature at a normal rate compared to a teen that has to take care of him or herself and lives in an environment with violence and drugs. Bethesda Maryland comes in 2nd place as the city with the highest income with a population of over 50,000 just behind Cupertino, California and above Greenwich, Connecticut. Some may argue that the richer cities have kids that are forked over money and then go use it to buy drugs. However, just by growing up in Bethesda, I know that kids are extra careful with what they get themselves into because everyone finds out everything and you would never want to tarnish your families reputation.
Some of the parents of the girls commented on the scandal and one father said, “They evidently got points for first, second and third base. They were going to have parties and tally up the points, and money was going to be exchanged at the end of the season.” He said that the boys would also have earned points for “schmoozing with the parents.” He also talked about how upset his daughter was and asked if this is really how we teach boys to treat women. He argued that teenage girls have enough to worry about so the added pressure that boys inflict is self- destructing. Another parent talked about how the girls felt targeted and completely used.
As I reflect on this scandal, I have realized that the norms of the society are changing because of the media and the environment in which the teens are raised. The only way we can put a stop to women being sexual prey is if we teach kids at a young age about the value of a woman as a human rather than an object.
Thursday, February 17, 2011
Animation Sexism?
Animated movies are a growing part of children’s lives. Whether they watch them with friends, with a babysitter, with their family, or in theatres; children are watching more and more animated films in modern day than ever before. The animated movie industry caters specifically to a child audience and creates good, whole-hearted family appropriate films that provide examplatory behavior and role models for children. Yet can this same industry, which seems so innocent, be installing sexist ideas in children’s heads that women have fought to abolish for so long? A recent article came out discussing Pixar’s films and the firing of Brenda Chapman, the first female Pixar director. The article, “Is Pixar Sexist? Anger as Studio Replaces Female Director on ‘Brave’” discusses the lack of women and their impact on the Pixar Company, and the lack of female lead roles in Pixar’s films. Pixar has yet to produce a film with a leading female role until now. Pixar’s new film, “Brave”, if untampered with, can be revolutionary in Pixar’s films because it stars a female lead and may in the long run help reduce sexism from a very young age.
Every Pixar film (Toy Story 1-3, Cars, Wall-e, Monsters Inc, The Incredibles, Finding Nemo, A Bug’s Life, Up and Ratatouille) has a male protagonist with females always in a supporting role. The female characters are never portrayed as role models and are simply additions into the films to make them more interesting. For example, in Wall-e the entire film is focused about Wall-e and his life on earth, and includes Eve as a side character who is only in the film because of Wall-e’s attraction to her. Eve may have respectable characteristics and be portrayed as kind and loving, but again is not the main character or meant to be a role model for young girls. This is also the same for Cars and Toy Story. In Toy Story 1, Little Bo Peep is seen as the typical damsel in distress and exemplifies the typical housewife Betty Friedan describes in her excerpt from The Feminine Mystique that so many women strived to be in the 50s and 60s. In Finding Nemo, Dori is portrayed as the mentally slower comical character that again has good characteristics, but is not meant for the leading role. The films focus on male characters and include females as less important characters. Since children learn from observation, this issue can greatly affect the way young females view themselves, the way they should act with other females and males, and lead to furthering male dominance in modern society.
But this article does not just focus on the lack of leading female characters in the films; it also focuses on the lack of leading female positions in the workplace. It seems almost as if Pixar makes an effort to keep women out of controlling positions in their films and workplace. The article states, “for one thing, the animation industry is not know as a warm and fuzzy place for women”, and only around 7 percent of directors were women in the entire Hollywood film industry (p.1). These facts show the increased difficulty there is for a woman rather than man seeking a job in the film industry, which many think of as to be a more modern and equal part of our society. It also shows how even though women have come such a far way to being completely equal with men, there is still hidden sexism in modern society. One of the main upsets with this issue was not only that Chapman had been the first female director for Pixar, but also that the movie she had written known as “Brave”, staring a female archer as the main character.
The film “Brave” is supposed to be about an archer-princess, who unlike all other Pixar films, plays the leading more masculine role in the film. The article quotes that the girl is the “impetuous, tangle-haired Merida, who despite being the daughter of a king and queen, would prefer to make her mark as a great archer”. This film will be enlightening and extremely important for children to see because it will hopefully start to break the male dominated animation world that children are so captivated by. It can also help decrease the stereotypes for girls and push women’s equality to the next level. Girls will now have an option of watching someone from their sex succeed and play the brave, courageous heroine role instead of just watching female characters be dependent on male characters. Some people fear that due to the director change, “Brave” may change and become more tailored to boys than girls. The final quote in the article perfectly describes not only the problems with gender in the film industry as well as in the films themselves. The article says,
“Gender matters,” wrote Kecky. "Yes, men and women are different. That’s precisely why it’s so important to have a balance between both perspectives, with equal respect given to each. Both movies and the movie industry are overrun with men. 'Brave' is also the first Pixar movie with a female main character, and personally, Chapman getting replaced by a man makes me worried that 'Brave' is going to get 'Tangled 'and made “more interesting to boys” as well."
Gender does matter. It matters in films and in the workplace. It is present in everyday life and makes up an enormous part of an individuals identity. So, when females are so blatantly ignored in the animation film industry it calls to question how progressive our society really is.
By creating this film “Brave”, Pixar is taking a step towards furthering women’s equality and reducing the sexism in society. “Brave” will hopefully allow young girls to think outside of societies image of a woman and her duties. Though Pixar may be sexist, by producing this film, Pixar can help breaking down sexism from a young age, enabling children to grow up in a less sexist environment, possibly leading to real equality for women.
Wednesday, February 16, 2011
Response Post
Leading Post: How Many Sexes Will Be Enough?
In "Should There Be Only Two Sexes" Fausto-Sterling problematize intersex infant procedures and how that process reaffirms the binary system. In this chapter she encourages a five sex system rather than a two sex system. She also advocates for the need to change the medical management of intersexual birth in three aspects: 1) stop unnecessary infant surgery (only for emergencies) 2) determine the sex with better knowledge (rather than based on penis size or vagina appearance) and 3) inform parents and child about the process. Fausto-Sterling provides many cases where the doctors decision on what sex the intersex child will be, in the future that decision what not of the best one and how it had negative effects on the child. Due to so many cases like that, many organization arose to enlighten and fight for intersex rights.
Too Many Sexes?
Monday, February 14, 2011
Responding Post
While reading "Dueling Dualisms," I thought about Caroline P (and other female athletes) and how they would have responded to Pierre de Coubertin's claim: "women's sports are all against the law of nature" (2-3). Although females have made it into the athletic realm, I think Coubertin's ideology still lives on. Besides the examples Fausto-Sterling provided in this chapter of females athletes being questioned for their gender, I can think of two recent highly publicized accounts of this: 1) South African runner, Caster Semenya (2009) and 2) the controversy over the age of the Chinese gymnastics in the 2008 Beijing Olympics. Even though, I didn't follow these two accounts in detail--I don't know the final results of these two examples--but all of these examples exemplify a common theme: the controversy of women sports seems to revolve around the idea of their ability to actually perform in their sport area (whether questioning their gender, their age, etc.). To follow this point, I don't think there is any mass media coverage on men sports that question their ability to play (and I don't consider Michael Phillips, ARod, and other males athletes who use drugs and steroids--these are external factors that can't compare to questionings a females age/gender/sex). Instead the media focuses on male athletics like OJ Simpson's murderer case, Tiger Woods sex scandal, etc.; all of these stories have nothing to do with the male athletes' biological makeup. The point being, society still embrace the idea that "sports are outside of "women's sports are all against the law of nature" (2-3).
In relation to Coraline C's post and the examples she provided, I also want to add how it seems with today's medical advancements the gender/sex guidelines seems to be more difficulty to define. However, trying to select which gender box one belongs in is not the problem, but the problem is the great amount of people who are actually trying to alter their bodies. To make it clear, I am not against a person wanting to become another gender they self identify better with, but my main concern is the ways people are altering their bodies to fit into what society portray as the "prefect" men or women. Just think about plastic surgery, breast implants, and facial or bodily alteration, etc. And it doesn't even have to be this extreme either, our alteration of our bodies include botox, hair growth products, anti-wrinkles creams, height alteration (heels). To think about it: is society really that scared of aging and looking unattractive? It seems bothersome that people are now actually are more and more deliberately changing themselves.
Lastly, what I liked about Fausto-Sterling is unlike other authors who don't give us the clear answer to what comes first (the chicken or the egg), she clearly states that "our beliefs about gender affects what kinds of knowledge scientists produce about sex in the first place" (3). In others words gender and sex are social constructs that we are in control of. Our first step can start with discarding this binary of only two genders (male and female) and start to openly accept and acknowledge the variations in the gender/sex spectrum.